7 1323 Reedster Jaydawg^814 Re: Bad call by umpire decides Game 2 of the ALCS [Reply to #1324] 10/23/05, 6:19pm That play was partially Mike Scioscia's fault because you should never have a rookie catcher (Josh Paul) in that type of situation in the ninth inning in a crucial playoff game. On a borderline play like that, a veteran catcher would've had the instinct to tag the batter out or throw it to first. [Jaydawg from Tarzana/CA] Replies: