438 5555 Jaydawg brian.joura^3336 Re: Jim Edmonds or Jim Rice - Which Player is More Hall Worthy? [Reply to #5557] 8/16/08, 6:46am Thanks for the reply Jaydawg! I have to disagree with your comment, though. In 2004, Jim Edmonds batted .301 with 42 home runs, 111 RBIs and a .643 slugging percentage, which was way, way more valuable than Rice in '86 or '75 - three seasons that each player's team went to the World Series. [brian.joura from Asheboro/NC] Replies: 5559