6 188 drrubb drrubb Re: The all star game is looking more like a popularity contest rather than a all star game! 6/3/06, 8:55pm (Last Edited: 6/3/06, 9:28pm) In my opinion, this is who should be the starting all star players for each league & their back ups(not based off fan voting, but their actual numbers/production. AL C - Joe Mauer 1B - Jim Thome 2B - Jose Lopez SS - Miguel Tejada 3B - Alex Rodriguez OF - Vlad Guerrero OF - Vernon Wells OF - Jermaine Dye DH - Travis Hafner (if there is one) AL Reserves: Alex Rios Manny Ramirez David Ortiz Derek Jeter Troy Glaus Ramon Hernandez Magglio Ordonez Nick Swisher Grady Sizemore Gary Matthews Jr. Kevin Mench Carl Crawford Robinson Cano Ichiro Suzuki Micheal Young AL Starting Pitchers: Roy Halladay Curt Schilling Scott Kazmir Mike Mussina Jose Contreras CC Sabathia Justin Verlander Barry Zito Johan Santana AL Relievers: Jon Papelbon BJ Ryan Fernando Rodney Bobby Jenks Chris Ray F. Rodriguez Mariano Rivera Joe Nathan Bob Wickman NL C - Paul Loduca 1B - Albert Pujols 2B - Chase Utley SS - Edgar Renteria 3B - Miguel Cabrera OF - Andruw Jones OF - Jason Bay OF - Alfonso Soriano DH - Matt Holliday (if there is one) NL Reserves: Ryan Howard Scott Rolen Lance Berkman Jose Castillo Pat Burrell Hanley Ramirez Jose Vidro Carlos Lee Prince Fielder Dan Uggla Jack Wilson Felipe Lopez David Wright Freddy Sanchez Brad Hawpe NL Starting Pitchers: Brandon Webb Derek Lowe Chris Carpenter Carlos Zambrano Brett Myers Pedro Martinez Bronson Arroyo Roy Oswalt John Smoltz NL Relievers: Trevor Hoffman Tom Gordon Brian Fuentes Jason Isringhausen Billy Wagner Roberto Hernandez Tod Coffey Kenneth Ray Chad Cordero [drrubb from Panama City Beach/Florida] Replies: 190