6 0 All drrubb The position players who shouldn't have been all stars. 7/3/07, 7:15am AL Ivan Rodriguez - much less the AL starting catcher. The starting AL catcher should be Victor Martinez or Jorge Posada. My vote, by a slight margin, Martinez. Micheal Young - a great player yes, but how did Orlando Cabrera not make the all start team? Here is how I would rank the AL shortstops going strictly by the numbers so far this season. 1. Carlos Guillen - should be the AL starting SS, NOT JETER! 2. Orlando Cabrera 3. Branden Harris - Yeah I said it! A Devil Ray! He has been better than Jeter this season. 4. Derek Jeter NL Brian McCann - ? Atleast he wasn't selected as the starter. Surely there is another NL catcher, besides Martin who has put up better first half numbers than McCann? Freddy Sanchez - the numbers just aren't there [drrubb from Panama City Beach/Florida] Replies: 247