1
381
JoeKool2322
Rob Reed
Re: Trade Advice <FONT COLOR=BLACK><b>[</font>Reply to #<a href="read.pl?3-381">381</a>]</b>
6/24/08, 12:37pm
>I am in a roto league and I just Polanco/Nady/Sherill for
>Kinsler/Bedard. What do you guys think?

Did you receive the offer or make it?

With this deal, I -- for one -- would not dump Kinsler for these guys.  He has been a top 5 fantasy player this year according to PlayerTrack.

Nady is Nady -- meaning... just not a guy who is going to help you much in the long haul.  Polanco has gotten his average up, but that's all you get.  Sherrill is not the prototypical valuable fantasy closer because of his other stats outside of saves.

Bedard, while an injury risk and while having his problems this season, is still a guy that folks should not want to part with ALONG WITH Kinsler.

So, if you offered this deal, hoping to get Kinsler/Bedard, it is a great deal for you (although any owner with even a little experience should not agree to this deal).  If you are making it, cancel it immediately.

[Rob Reed from Sylmar/CA]
Replies: